• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
BlackDoctor.org
Where Wellness & Culture Connect

Where Wellness & Culture Connect

  • Health Conditions
  • Wellness
  • Lifestyle
  • Longevity
  • COVID-19
  • Find A Doctor
  • Subscribe
Home / / Cancer Screenings: Is Your Doctor Telling You The Benefits AND Risks?

Cancer Screenings: Is Your Doctor Telling You The Benefits AND Risks?

doctor talking to patientKEY POINTS

  • Only 27 percent of women screened for breast cancer, 38 percent of men and women being screened for colorectal cancer and 34 percent of men screened for prostate cancer reported the physician using shared decision making during screening discussions.
  • Physicians were more likely to discuss the pros of cancer screening than the cons.
  • Physicians were more likely to present screening as an option to men than to women.

 

A national survey of patients reveals that physicians don’t always fully discuss the risks and benefits of cancer screening, reports a new study in American Journal of Preventive Medicine.

The study examined data from more than 1100 people aged 50 and older who made decisions about whether to undergo screening for breast cancer, colorectal cancer, or prostate cancer in the previous 2 years. Participants were asked whether their physicians discussed the pros and cons of screening and of forgoing screening, and if they had been given a choice whether or not to be screened.

Shared decision making was reported by only 27 percent of women for breast cancer screening, 38 percent of both women and men for colorectal screening, and 34 percent for men for prostate screening. Survey participants reported that physicians were more likely to discuss the pros of a given screening procedure (51 percent to 67 percent, depending on the type of screening) than the cons (7 percent to 14 percent). Furthermore, most physicians offered opinions that primarily favored screening.

Physicians were also reported to be more likely to ask men (71 percent for colorectal cancer and 70 percent for prostate cancer) whether they wanted testing than they were to ask women (43 percent for breast cancer and 57 percent for colorectal cancer).

You May Also Like
9 Foods You Should Never Eat after Age 30

Ideally, in shared decision making, a physician informs a patient that a decision is needed, invites  them to weigh in on the decision, and provides him or her with information about the risks and benefits of both testing/treatment or doing nothing. Ideally, the physician also helps the patient make a decision that considers the patient’s values and preferences about their health and health care.

Overall, 77 percent of patients decided to participate in the three cancer screenings studied, ranging from 69 percent of women for colorectal cancer to 93 percent of men for prostate cancer. The majority said they were confident about their decision; however, those who reported their physicians were primarily responsible for the decision were less confident than those making a shared decision.

The authors also compared shared decision making discussions with women in their 40s versus women over 50 because of recent controversy over the appropriateness of breast cancer screening for younger women and were surprised by the result.

“We were expecting that decision making quality would be better for younger women and it wasn’t,” said Richard M. Hoffman, MD, MPH, professor of internal medicine at the University of New Mexico School of Medicine in Albuquerque and lead author on the study. “Overall, we didn’t see that much shared decision making.”

You May Also Like
The Most Common STD You've Never Heard Of

“The methodology [the authors] used and their interpretation of data is correct,” said Richard Wender, MD, chief cancer control officer with the American Cancer Society in Atlanta and coauthor of the guidelines that urge shared decision making for prostate cancer screening. However, he said that extrapolating from the results should be done cautiously. “Medicine will have to grapple with what kinds of physician advice should be moved into shared decision making as opposed to traditional recommendations to have it done,” he said.

“Shared decision making is difficult to do,” Wender added. “Tools and guidance about how to do it are not as easily available as they should be.”

 

Visit the BlackDoctor.org Cancer center for more articles.

This articles was originally published by Health Behavior News Service, part of the Center for Advancing Health.

 

 

June 13, 2014 by Valerie DeBenedette, HBNS Contributing Writer

Read Next Article

The Latest In

Gloria Richardson: A Civil Rights Force Still Going Strong

One of the most influential leaders of the Civil Rights movement, Gloria Richardson remains, at 98 years strong, an undeniable figure in not just Black or Civil Rights history, but American history. Some people even call her the "Second Harriet read more about Gloria Richardson: A Civil Rights Force Still Going Strong

Chicago Comedian, Erica Watson, Dies at 48

Beautiful. Funny. Kind. Generous. Immensely creative. The words that describe the Chicago born actress and comedian, Erica Watson, could go on and on. Unfortunately, the laughs stopped on Saturday February 27, 2021, 1 day after Watson's 48th Birthday, when she read more about Chicago Comedian, Erica Watson, Dies at 48

8 clever ways to get Vaccinated RIGHT NOW

As more states roll out their vaccination program, many persons are anxious to know if they qualify and how to get vaccinated as soon as possible. To make sure you’re in line for those important injections, here’s what you need read more about 8 clever ways to get Vaccinated RIGHT NOW

C.D.C. Finds Covid Outbreaks in Gyms

  Federal health officials found that coronavirus cases at fitness centers in Chicago and Honolulu were caused by misuse of masks and carelessness about symptoms. Gym members and guests are supposed to wear masks when they work out and keep read more about C.D.C. Finds Covid Outbreaks in Gyms

Tasha Smith at 50: “Your Dream is the Best Gift You’ve Got”

The daughter of a single mother who gave birth at 15 to her and her twin sister Sidra, actress and director Tasha Smith grew up around gangs, drugs and poverty in Camden, N.J., a city that one time was named read more about Tasha Smith at 50: “Your Dream is the Best Gift You’ve Got”

You A’ight, Bro? 4 Reasons Why Black Men Need Therapy RIGHT NOW

Only one in three African-Americans who need mental healthcare receive it. The numbers are even grimmer when we consider Black men's mental wellness.  For the past few decades, there has been growing interest in improving Black men's health and the read more about You A’ight, Bro? 4 Reasons Why Black Men Need Therapy RIGHT NOW

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to our newsletter

Poll

Popular Posts

  • 7 Bad Sleep Habits That Cause Weight Gain7 Bad Sleep Habits That Cause Weight Gain
  • Home Remedies For Your Dry SkinHome Remedies For Your Dry Skin
  • Pooch Hall: Family Over EverythingPooch Hall: Family Over Everything
  • 7 Turnoffs Men Wish Women Knew7 Turnoffs Men Wish Women Knew
  • ‘Madea’ Actress Natalie Desselle-Reed Dies at 53'Madea' Actress Natalie Desselle-Reed Dies at 53

Podcast

Diabetes prevention and management podcast

Dr. LeNoir is joined by Dr. Lenore Coleman, a Pharmacist and Founder of Healing Our Village, as they offer you the tools you need to prevent and manage diabetes.

Listen Now

Footer

Where Wellness & Culture Connect

BDO is the world’s largest and most comprehensive online health resource specifically targeted to African Americans. BDO understands that the uniqueness of Black culture - our heritage and our traditions - plays a role in our health. BDO gives you access to innovative new approaches to the health information you need in everyday language so you can break through the disparities, gain control and live your life to its fullest.

Connect With Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Learn More About

  • Hepatitis C
  • Diabetes
  • Sickle Cell
  • Mental Health
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise With Us
  • BlackDoctor.org Advertising and Sponsorship Policy
  • Daily Vitamina
  • TBH

Copyright © 2021, BlackDoctor, Inc. All rights reserved.