Artificial Intelligence (AI) is reshaping healthcare by enhancing diagnostics, personalizing treatments, and streamlining administrative processes. However, for Black patients, AI presents significant challenges that could worsen racial disparities in medicine. Biases embedded within AI systems—whether in diagnosis, treatment recommendations, or predictive analytics—can result in misdiagnoses, inadequate treatment, and systemic neglect of Black patients’ health concerns.
Understanding how AI-driven bias affects Black patients and knowing how to advocate for equitable healthcare is essential in this new digital age.
How AI Algorithms Reinforce Racial Disparities
AI-powered healthcare tools are designed to analyze vast amounts of patient data and assist doctors in making decisions. However, these systems reflect the biases present in their training data, often leading to discrimination against Black patients.
1. Biased Training Data: AI Learns from Historical Racism
Most AI models are trained on historical healthcare data, which is already riddled with racial disparities. Since Black patients have historically received lower-quality healthcare, AI trained on these records learns to replicate these same patterns.
You May Also Like
Example: A 2019 study published in Science found that an AI system used by major hospitals to predict healthcare needs favored white patients over Black patients, even when Black patients had more severe health conditions. The reason? The AI used healthcare spending as a proxy for health needs, and because historically, less money is spent on Black patients, the algorithm falsely assumed they required less care.
2. AI Uses Cost as a Proxy for Health Needs
Many healthcare algorithms predict which patients need urgent care based on how much money is typically spent on their treatment. Since Black patients historically receive less investment in their healthcare, these systems underestimate their medical needs and direct more resources to white patients.
Example: A 2021 study in The New England Journal of Medicine found that Black patients were less likely to be referred for specialized care because AI models assumed they were “less sick” based on historical spending patterns rather than actual medical conditions.
3. AI Fails to Diagnose Diseases in Black Patients
AI-driven diagnostic tools—like skin cancer detection software, radiology imaging models, and voice analysis tools—are often trained on predominantly white patient data, making them less accurate for Black patients.
Examples of AI’s Diagnostic Failures:
- Dermatology AI models are less effective on darker skin, leading to missed diagnoses for conditions like melanoma.
- AI-driven lung scans may fail to detect pneumonia in Black patients because most training data comes from white patients.
- Voice-based diagnostic AI used in mental health screenings often misinterprets Black patients’ speech patterns, leading to misdiagnoses of mood disorders.
Why AI-Driven Diagnoses Fail Black People
Several systemic issues contribute to the failure of AI-powered healthcare for Black patients:
1. Underrepresentation in Medical Imaging
AI models trained on medical images (X-rays, MRIs, CT scans) often lack sufficient data from Black patients. This results in:
- Missed diagnoses for conditions like lung disease and breast cancer.
- Higher error rates in AI-assisted radiology scans.
- Slower detection of diseases, delaying treatment for Black patients.
Fact: A 2022 study in The Lancet Digital Health found that Black women are 30 percent more likely to receive false-negative results in AI-assisted mammograms, delaying early breast cancer detection.
2. Medical Devices Are Less Accurate for Darker Skin
- Pulse oximeters, which measure blood oxygen levels, perform worse on Black patients because they were designed for lighter skin tones.
- AI-powered wearable health devices (such as Fitbits and smartwatches) struggle to read heart rates on darker skin accurately.
- Ophthalmology AI tools that scan for diabetes-related eye diseases often fail to detect early-stage symptoms in Black patients.
Example: The FDA issued a warning in 2021 that pulse oximeters were less accurate for Black patients, increasing the risk of undetected respiratory distress during COVID-19.
3. AI Perpetuates Stigma and Bias from Medical Records
Many AI systems read electronic health records (EHRs) to predict patient outcomes, but these records often contain racial bias. Doctors’ notes can include coded language that influences AI decisions.
Example: Terms like “non-compliant” or “difficult patient” are more frequently used in Black patients’ records due to implicit bias. AI reads these notes and falsely predicts worse health outcomes, leading to less aggressive treatment plans.
A 2020 study found that Black patients were 2.5 times more likely to have negative descriptors in their medical records than white patients.
RELATED: 10 Ways Nutritionists Are Using AI to Transform What We Eat
How Black Patients Can Ensure Better Treatment in Digital Healthcare
While AI in healthcare is far from perfect, Black patients can advocate for equitable care by taking proactive steps:
1. Demand Diversity in AI Training Data
- Ask hospitals and clinics: “Was this AI system tested on Black patients?
- Advocate for diverse clinical trials that include Black participants.
- Support organizations pushing for bias audits in AI healthcare tools.
The NIH launched an initiative in 2022 to improve diversity in AI-driven medical research, but more work is needed.
2. Push for AI Transparency and Bias Audits
- Hospitals and insurers should disclose when AI is used in patient care.
- AI systems should undergo regular bias audits to identify racial disparities.
- Patients should have the right to challenge AI-generated health decisions.
If an AI-driven diagnosis seems inaccurate, demand a second opinion from a human doctor.
3. Encourage Inclusive Clinical Trials
- Black patients should participate in clinical trials to ensure AI tools are tested on diverse populations.
- Ask your doctor: “Are there clinical trials that include Black patients for this condition?”
Less than five percent of clinical trial participants are Black, leading to inequitable AI healthcare tools.
4. Advocate for AI in Healthcare Policy Reform
- Push for legislation requiring racial bias testing in AI medical tools.
- Support Black-led tech and medical innovation groups working to create equitable AI solutions.
- Vote for policies that promote health equity in digital medicine.
The Algorithmic Accountability Act (proposed in 2022) aims to regulate AI bias in healthcare, but it needs public support.
Holding AI Accountable for Black Health Equity
AI has the potential to revolutionize healthcare, but if racial bias isn’t addressed, it will continue to reinforce health disparities. Black patients can demand equitable healthcare in the digital age by advocating for diverse data, bias audits, inclusive clinical trials, and AI transparency.
