What Counts as a HIPAA Violation?
A HIPAA violation occurs when a covered entity (such as a healthcare provider, health plan, or healthcare clearinghouse) or its business associate improperly accesses, discloses, or mishandles your Protected Health Information (PHI)—that is, personal data that can identify you, like medical history or Social Security number.
Common examples include:
- Unauthorized access, such as someone viewing your medical data without permission.
- Data breaches from cyberattacks or poor security.
- Improper disposal of records—e.g., falling in a trash bin unshredded.
- Unconsented sharing, such as posting PHI on social media.
- Lack of staff training causing the mishandling of PHI.
Should You Raise the Issue?
You should speak up if you suspect your privacy has been violated. Reporting early:
You May Also Like
- Mitigates further harm to your PHI.
- Supports accountability and systemic improvement within healthcare organizations.
Fear of retaliation shouldn’t deter you—HIPAA protects “whistleblowers,” shielding employees who report violations in good faith from wrongful termination, harassment, or discrimination.
Why the Chronically Ill Are Most at Risk
When it comes to HIPAA breaches, not all patients face equal levels of vulnerability. While anyone can experience a privacy violation, patients living with chronic illnesses—such as diabetes, heart disease, cancer, HIV, or autoimmune conditions—are disproportionately at risk. Their heightened exposure stems from several overlapping factors: increased medical interactions, reliance on digital tools, stigmatization, and systemic inequities in healthcare.
More Frequent Healthcare Interactions
Chronic illnesses require ongoing care, including regular doctor visits, lab tests, pharmacy pickups, imaging scans, and consultations with multiple specialists. Each touchpoint increases the number of individuals and systems handling sensitive Protected Health Information (PHI).
For example:
You May Also Like
- A patient with diabetes may see an endocrinologist, primary care doctor, eye specialist, dietitian, and pharmacist, all of whom may share PHI.
- A cancer survivor may undergo years of follow-up imaging, genetic testing, and insurance pre-authorizations—each interaction representing a potential privacy risk.
The more times PHI is stored, transmitted, or accessed, the greater the chance it could be misused or exposed.
Higher Dependence on Insurance and Third Parties
Chronically ill patients often depend heavily on insurance companies, Medicare, or Medicaid to manage the cost of long-term care. This involves repeated sharing of detailed medical records for:
- Prior authorizations
- Disability or leave claims
- Prescription drug coverage
Every handoff between a healthcare provider, insurer, and sometimes even third-party vendors (like pharmacy benefit managers) expands the risk of data mishandling. The Office of Civil Rights has repeatedly fined insurers and health plans for failing to protect data in transmission (HHS OCR).
Increased Digital Surveillance and Data Sharing
Today, patients with chronic illnesses are encouraged—or sometimes pressured—to use apps, wearables, and portals to track their health. While convenient, these tools often exist in a gray area between HIPAA-regulated and consumer health apps, which are governed instead by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
For example:
- A blood pressure tracking app might share data with advertisers if not covered by HIPAA.
- Remote monitoring devices used for telehealth can transmit PHI over unsecured channels if not properly encrypted.
Because chronically ill patients rely more heavily on these tools, they face greater digital exposure than patients with temporary health needs.
Stigma and Sensitive Health Information
Some chronic conditions—especially those associated with mental health, reproductive health, or infectious disease—carry social stigma. A breach of this information can have severe consequences:
- An HIV-positive patient’s status being improperly disclosed could lead to discrimination in housing, employment, or relationships.
- Mental health therapy notes being leaked might harm a patient’s reputation or career.
- Reproductive health data (e.g., related to fertility or miscarriage) may have heightened risks in today’s post-Roe legal environment.
For these patients, the impact of a breach isn’t just financial—it’s deeply personal and potentially life-altering.
Structural Inequities Make Risks Worse
Finally, HIPAA risks intersect with systemic health disparities. Black, Indigenous, and other patients of color are more likely to suffer from chronic illnesses due to structural inequities in healthcare access, environmental exposures, and economic opportunity.
Because these groups are overrepresented among the chronically ill:
- They face more frequent interactions with healthcare systems.
- They are disproportionately affected by underfunded hospitals or clinics, which may have weaker cybersecurity protections.
- They have less access to legal recourse or may mistrust institutions, making them less likely to report breaches.
Thus, privacy violations compound existing inequities—placing the burden on communities already facing health and social vulnerabilities.
Chronically ill patients are at greater risk of HIPAA breaches not just because of their medical needs, but also due to systemic, technological, and social factors. Their reliance on ongoing care, digital tools, and insurance—combined with the potential stigma of certain diagnoses—makes the consequences of privacy violations especially severe.
Knowing—& Using—Your Rights
(a) Document the Concern
Before making a complaint, gather clear and thorough details:
- What happened?
- When did it happen? Date and time.
- Who was involved—staff names or roles.
- What specific PHI was disclosed?
- Collect any evidence (emails, screenshots)—but avoid copying unauthorized PHI.
(b) Report Internally (If Applicable)
If you’re affiliated with the healthcare institution (e.g., as a patient, staffer, or family), file through your organization’s internal Privacy Officer or other designated process. Organizations should have information on this in their “Notice of Privacy Practices” or patient materials.
(c) File a Complaint with HHS OCR
You or anyone may lodge a formal complaint with the HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR), online or in writing. The OCR investigates perceived violations and enforces HIPAA compliance.
(d) Filing a Breach Notification Request
Under the Breach Notification Rule, covered entities must notify:
- Individuals affected.
- OCR (by using the online form).
- Media, if the breach affects over 500 residents in a region.
If you don’t receive proper notifications—or the entity denies wrongdoing despite evidence—you can challenge it through OCR.
(e) Know Your Legal Protections
HIPAA violations carry steep penalties:
- Civil fines range from $100 to over $50,000 per violation; in cases of willful neglect not corrected promptly, penalties can reach $1.5 million annually.
- Criminal penalties can include fines up to $250,000 and imprisonment for knowing and improper disclosures.
- Reporting violations in good faith is protected under whistleblower provisions.
(f) Keep Following Up
Ensure that:
- Your internal complaint is acknowledged and investigated.
- If internal paths fail, escalate to OCR.
- If the breach involves other regulators (e.g., FTC for apps), those channels may also apply Federal Trade Commission.
Step-by-Step Summary
- Identify if PHI was mishandled (unauthorized access, disclosure, etc.)
- Document all details—what, when, who, how.
- Report internally to the organization’s Privacy Officer.
- File with OCR, if internal resolution is insufficient.
- Monitor breach notification obligations, including media and OCR filings.
- Know your rights and penalties—HIPAA safeguards you and can penalize noncompliance.
- Follow up and escalate if needed.
If you suspect your healthcare privacy has been breached, speaking up isn’t just your right—it’s a critical step in safeguarding your information and improving protections for everyone.
